| Oftel's Broadband and Internet Brief - January 2002 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Narrowband access |
|
|
% UK homes with Internet access |
45% |
|
% UK SMEs with Internet access |
63% |
|
Number of UK homes with Internet access |
11 million |
|
Number of UK SMEs * with Internet access |
643,000 |
|
Broadband access |
|
|
Cable modems |
|
|
End-users of cable modem services |
196,000 (as at end December 2001) |
|
Availability of cable modems |
- Telewest available to 4.9m homes - 95% broadband capable - ntl available to 8.4m homes - 56% broadband capable |
|
DSL |
|
|
UK households covered by DSL |
60% (around 15 million homes) |
|
End-users with ADSL installed |
|
|
Operators and service providers that have taken up BT's wholesale ADSL products |
200 |
|
BT exchanges DSL enabled |
1010 |
* SMEs are defined as businesses with 1-250 employees and minimum turnover of £50,000.
Key events since the previous brief
Forthcoming events
2.1 Monitoring the Internet and broadband access market
Oftel regularly monitors the UK Internet and broadband access markets and publishes its findings to aid transparency. Oftel’s International benchmarking study takes place every 6 months. The latest set of results from Oftel’s benchmarking studies of dial-up Internet access, published in December 2001(based on services available in August 2001), includes the UK, France, Germany, Sweden, and the US states of Ohio and California. Oftel’s quarterly market research surveys ask residential and SME Internet users about their use and experience of the Internet, along with consumer awareness and use of broadband technologies.
2.2 Availability
Narrowband
For residential and business users:
Broadband
For residential and business users:
2.3 Take-up
Narrowband
For residential users (November 2001 survey):
For business users (November 2001 survey):
Broadband
For residential broadband users:
For business broadband users (November 2001 survey):
2.4 Pricing (December 2001 international benchmarking survey, prices as at August 2001)
Narrowband
For residential dial-up users:

Source: Oftel International benchmarking report, December 2001
For business dial-up users:
Source: Oftel International benchmarking report, December 2001
Broadband
For residential broadband (DSL and cable modem) users:

Source: Oftel International benchmarking report, December 2001
For business broadband (DSL and cable modem) users:

Source: Oftel International benchmarking report, December 2001
2.3 The International benchmarking study is expected to be updated (for services available in February 2002) with publication expected in May 2002. In addition to the quarterly consumer surveys, Oftel has recently commissioned research looking at UK residential consumers’ use and perceptions of broadband Internet services, including demand for services, benefits, costs consumers are prepared to pay, driving factors and switching behaviour. Results from this research will be published in January 2002.
Oftel is also proposing to carry out an additional benchmarking exercise to establish whether, and if so, why, UK consumers are making more or less use of Internet broadband access than other countries. The results are expected to be available early next year.
3.1 Current technology
The UK has a vibrant dial-up (also known as ‘narrowband’) ISP market with both pay-as-you-go and unmetered packages available to consumers. Industry sources estimate that there are over 400 ISPs operating in the UK. Unlike much of the rest of Europe (including Germany and France), an offshoot of the incumbent does not dominate the competitive UK dial-up retail market. Over 80% of online households and 76% of SMEs with Internet access use a dial-up PSTN connection to the Internet. A further 9% of households and 23% of SMEs access the Internet via a dial-up ISDN line.
3.2 Current product offerings
There are a number of dial-up Internet access packages available to both residential and business consumers. These include:
Metered
The UK pioneered the pay-as-you-go model, which has been copied by many other countries. Packages are now available which offer consumers Internet access at rates below the price of local-rate voice calls. Some packages include a monthly subscription fee in addition to the cost of calls, whereas others are ‘subscription-free’.
Subscription-free Internet access led to a rapid growth in the number of Internet users in the UK, and is likely to remain a good option for occasional or light users, and those who do not want to commit to a contract. However, the number of consumers using pay-as-you-go packages has fallen as more unmetered services have become available. In November 2001, 61% of Internet households were using metered packages to access the Internet (21% subscription-based, 40% subscription-free).
Unmetered
Unmetered packages can be fully or partly unmetered and have been available for some time. However, the availability and take-up of unmetered packages has grown significantly over the last 12 months. This is partly the result of Oftel’s directions requiring BT to make available unmetered wholesale Internet access products (called FRIACO, see below). This has allowed more ISPs to compete in offering unmetered access and offer greater choice to consumers. Several ISPs offer FRIACO-based, fully unmetered retail packages for around £12.99 - £14.99 a month.
BT’s SurfTime Internet access products include unmetered Internet calls for a fixed monthly fee, as well as offering cheaper pay-as-you-go prices and discounted telephone calls. However, they do not include the costs of Internet service provision: in addition to SurfTime, consumers need to purchase Internet service provision from a participating ISP.
The Cable operators also offer their customers unmetered Internet access. Some of these unmetered packages require customers to spend a certain amount of money on their telephone calls each month.
In November 2001, 39% of Internet homes claimed to use some type of unmetered access (28% fully unmetered and 11% partly unmetered). Oftel estimates that three and a half million customers already subscribe to unmetered packages.
3.3 Alternative means of dial-up Internet access
Mobile
The mobile phone will be another important technology for accessing the Internet (70% of the UK population are mobile subscribers). Services like these are already available - Oftel research shows that 7% of UK residential consumers owns a WAP mobile phone. With the introduction of ‘2½ G’ technologies providing higher data rate communications, WAP services are becoming faster and therefore more user friendly.
So-called "2½ G" technologies, such as General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) which allows packet data transmission on GSM networks have been deployed by BT Cellnet and Vodafone. GPRS data rates will be up to 40kbps initially. BT Cellnet launched the first GPRS service to business customers in June 2000. BT Cellnet and Vodafone now both offer consumer and business GPRS products. Orange already offers a High-Speed Circuit Switched Data (HSCSD) product to business customers, which provides data rates of 28.8 kbps.
Television
Access to the Internet via the television is likely to become increasingly common as web-enabled TV set-top boxes and games consoles become more popular. Consumers can also buy web-enabled TVs (for example, the Bush TV that simply uses the TV as a monitor). These devices are already available and are being used by a small number of consumers. Accessing the Internet in this way may be more convenient for some people who cannot afford, or do not like the complexity or using a computer. Latest published figures show that over 8.5 million UK households have digital television. For more information on satellite access see satellite broadband below.
3.4 What is Oftel doing?
Oftel has taken action in a number of areas relating to dial-up Internet access to ensure fair competition.
Pricing of voice and Internet calls
In November 1999, Oftel removed the link between the pricing of Internet calls and price of voice calls to enable ISPs to price more flexibly.
FRIACO (flat rate Internet access call origination)
In May 2000, Oftel made a direction requiring BT to make available an unmetered wholesale Internet access product (called FRIACO) to enable other network operators to offer their own unmetered Internet access products in competition with BT. In February 2001 Oftel required BT to offer other network operators a new wholesale unmetered Internet access product known as ST FRIACO (Single Tandem FRIACO).
At present, Oftel is facilitating industry discussions on the feasibility of enhancements to the existing FRIACO products and on the development of a new IP interconnection FRIACO product . IP interconnection would provide a more efficient means for operators to connect to BT’s network and has been recognised as the best long-term option for handling the growth in dial-up Internet traffic. In addition, Oftel is reviewing the FRIACO adjustment ratio, which is used to calculate the price of FRIACO.
Effective competition reviews of dial-up Internet access
Oftel’s 2000/01 effective competition review of dial-up Internet access was published in July 2001. Oftel carries out effective competition reviews to assess the level of competition in a particular sector and to ensure that regulation is appropriate. Oftel has measured levels of competition against a number of indicators including price, consumer behaviour and market shares. A separate effective competition review of Internet connectivity was published in August 2001. Oftel has consulted widely on both reviews – the deadline for each was 30 October 2001. Oftel is due to publish a joint final statement on effective competition in the New Year (2002).
Oftel Internet Forum
In order to communicate with the Internet community more effectively, Oftel established a dedicated forum called the Oftel Internet Forum (OIF). This supplements Oftel’s existing regular meetings with key companies, trade bodies and consumer groups. Oftel uses the Forum to gain opinions and ideas about key regulatory developments. It is also used to inform the Internet community of key regulatory developments. The OIF meets about four times a year, each time addressing a particular issue.
Minutes of previous meetings:
19 September - ISPs' terms and conditions
23 March 2001 - Internet consumers - well informed and adequately represented?
The UK has one of the most competitive marketplaces in Europe for broadband, with competition at the infrastructure level between cable providers and DSL and numerous service providers competing with BT to provide retail DSL services to customers. Operators have the choice of local loop unbundling, shared access, wholesale services and now xDSL interconnection services with which to deliver broadband over BT’s network, while we have been careful to ensure that incentives to invest in alternative infrastructures are not undermined.
There is also some limited provision by fixed radio that, together with mobile radio and satellite technologies, should in future also be able to deliver broadband services more widely. Larger business users access broadband services via leased lines.
Downstream data rates (from the network to the customer) are usually higher than upstream rates (from the customer to the network) since the kind of information that needs to get to the user - including still and video images and sound - requires a higher data rate. Data rates on the upstream path can be smaller since user responses usually involve small quantities of data only e.g text.
4.1 Broadband Cable
Both Ntl and Telewest offer high-speed Internet access over their cable networks via cable modems. Data rates are 512kbps downstream and 128kbps upstream.
Telewest charges £50 connection and a monthly fee of £33 or £25 if you subscribe to other Telewest services. Ntl charges £25 for installation and either £150 for the modem and a £20 monthly fee, or a monthly charge of £25 including the cost of the modem. Customers can also pay around £30 per month to receive telephone and digital television services bundled with broadband Internet access.
Most of Ntl and Telewest’s cable networks are broadband ready, but not all. Both operators are working to upgrade their networks where necessary. The availability of NTL's service has increased as the service has been made available to 500,000 more potential subscribers in the South East by the end of 2001. NTL's availability has now increased to 56% from 50%.
According to publicly available figures at the end of December 2001, Ntl has around 101,000 customers of their cable modem service (up from 52,000 in July 2001) while Telewest reports that it has around 95,000 cable modem customers (up from 38,000 in July 2001).
4.2 Digital subscriber line (DSL)
DSL creates a high-speed digital connection over an existing telephone line using a pair of modems, one at the user end and the other at the Exchange. DSL is the major competing access technology to broadband cable.
4.2.1 Competition between service providers: BT’s wholesale Asymmetric Digital Subscriber Line (‘ADSL’) Service
The downstream data rate of ADSL is much higher than the upstream data rate. DSL is a distance-dependant technology, which means that it is normally available to those consumers who live within 3.5km of their local exchange.
BT's key products are:
There are around 200 operators, service providers and corporates that have signed a contract for BT’s wholesale ADSL products, including BT’s own service provider, BTOpenworld, which we estimate has around 50% of the market. The number of end users with ADSL installed (using BT or a BT re-seller) is increasing at a rate of around 10,000 per month and stood at 126,000 as of the end of December 2001. Around 30% of these end-users are businesses. There are a further 10,000 ADSL end-users who are customers of Kingston communications.
BT has enabled 1010 exchanges covering 60% of households for the delivery of ADSL wholesale products (up from 839 exchanges covering 50% of UK households in May 2001). BT has made no commitments regarding roll-out past this date though is working with development agencies to develop broadband services in rural areas. Information on rollout is available at www.bt.com/broadband
On 1 September, BT reduced its wholesale monthly rental charge for IP Stream 500 from £35 to £30 a month to enable BT’s wholesale customers to stimulate take up by end users. The connection charge for VideoStream was also reduced from £625 to £50 for 6 months from 1 October 2001. Wholesale rental charges fell further on 15 January when BT introduced self-install variants of its IPStream products, called IPStream Home & Office. Connection charges were reduced to £50 (ex VAT) with monthly rental charges starting at £25 (ex VAT) for IPStream Home. However, the end-user must also buy or rent a DSL modem.
Kingston Communications introduced its own wholesale ADSL product, RapidTime, on 4 October. The product is currently only offered by Kingston’s own ISP, Karoo.
For more details on future developments, pricing and what Oftel is doing, click here [ADSL fact sheet].
4.2.2 Local Loop Unbundling ('LLU')
LLU enables competing operators and service providers to create their own ADSL products rather than having to buy BT’s ADSL products on a wholesale basis. Under LLU, operators and service providers are able to install their own equipment in BT's exchanges in order to offer their own broadband services to end users.
The LLU condition in BT's licence came into force on 8th August 2000. This sets the legal framework and obligations on BT and gives Oftel powers to act if problems occur. In addition, the EC Regulation on LLU came into force on 2nd January 2001. Since then, there has been an intensive programme of work by BT, other operators and Oftel to set the technical and operational framework for the LLU process. Where necessary, Oftel has been fully prepared to act speedily to resolve any disputes.
Oftel has recently issued a number of documents relating to LLU. In summary these are:
Oftel has set out the service levels that BT must offer to operators wishing to unbundle BT’s local loop. The direction has set out the compensation that BT must pay to operators, where it fails to meet these service levels. For example BT will have to pay operators £10 for each working day an unbundled loop is unavailable and £80 per operator for each working day’s delay in providing co-location facilities.
Oftel has determined that operators can have unescorted access to BT’s exchanges in order to carry out maintenance on their equipment, unless escorted access is required for BT’s own contractors.
LLU backhaul is a wholesale service, which provides a link between an operator’s equipment at a BT exchange and an operator's point of interconnection with BT’s network. Oftel is proposing that BT be required to provide backhaul services at a cost oriented price.
Direction on certain of BT’s charges for distant and physical co-location
http://www.oftel.gov.uk/publications/broadband/llu/llup0102.htm
Oftel issued a final statement and direction on certain LLU charges for physical and distant co-location on 18 January 2002. The direction reduces the charges BT can levy for escorted access, reduces the charges for the MPF line characteristic check, sets a pricing methododolgy for external tie cables and removes a contingency charge from the price of external tie cables.
For more details on what is happening on LLU and what Oftel is doing, please see the Local Loop Unbundling Fact Sheet.
Leased lines are permanent high capacity telecommunications links supplied by network operators to predominantly business users, providing dedicated capacity to the user. Operators and services providers also use leased lines to supply, for example, backhaul for mobile networks and connections to the Internet for Internet Service Providers. Leased lines may be provided at a variety of bandwidths. These range from analogue to digital circuits up to 622 Mbps.
Oftel initiated a review of the national leased line market as a result of concerns about the extent of competition in this market (particularly on the wholesale side). In August 2000, Oftel published a consultation document on national leased lines, which found the market not to be effectively competitive. In the light of responses to the consultation document and a request from Energis for a direction in relation to permanent private circuits (PPCs), there have been several major developments in Oftel’s national leased lines policy:
1. Following consultation, Oftel issued a final Direction to BT on 29 March 2001 allowing BT eight weeks to conclude negotiations with ten operators regarding the provision of cost orientated PPCs at all bandwidths. The Direction allowed BT a further six weeks thereafter to make the products available to all Annex 2 operators. Constructive negotiations between BT and OLOs continued past the initial eight week stage and resulted in the OLOs signing commercial agreements with BT for the provision of PPCs.
2. BT launched PPCs on 1 August 2001 and since then, approximately two thirds of operators' retail private circuits which were eligible for migration have been migrated to the wholesale product. The availability of wholesale PPCs at all bandwidths makes it possible for operators to achieve cost savings of over 30%.
3. Since 1 August , Oftel has received requests for determinations on a number of issues from seven of the OLOs. OFTEL has decided to deal with some of the issues on a `fast track' basis and to issue a Determination on them within a substantially reduced timescale compared to normal determinations. The remaining, more complex issues will be determined by the end of January 2002.
Oftel will publish a final statement on the state of competition in the leased lines market alongside the second Determination described above. The statement will include Oftel’s conclusions on the need to regulate wholesale prices on some or all partial private circuits, in the light of developments following the March Direction and Oftel’s decisions on the most recent disputes.
4.5 Broadband Fixed Wireless Access
Broadband fixed wireless access ('BWA') allows high-speed data connections using radio links between an aerial located on the user's premises and a base station, rather than using a telephone line or a cable television network.
Tele 2 currently offers commercial BWA data-only services for business and residential users in the Thames Valley, (Reading, Wokingham, Bracknell, Windsor, Slough), Leicester, Nottingham, Coventry, Leeds, Bradford, Uxbridge (including Heathrow), Crystal Palace (inclduing Croydon) and Bristol using spectrum at 3.4GHz. Additional cities due this quarter are Birmingham, Bath and Sheffield.
The Radiocommunications Agency ('RA') auctioned spectrum for BWA at 28GHz in December 2000. Energis, Norweb, Faultbasic, Broadnet, Chorus Communication and Eircom won licences in seven out of fourteen regions, collectively covering 60% of the UK's population. There were no bidders in the remaining seven regions. There is no current commercial deployment and no times given by the winners as to when they might deploy, although trials have started in at least one area.
The 28GHz licences that were not awarded in the auction will be made available from mid October 2001 at the original reserve prices (varying from £1 to £2 million), and with the same conditions as previously (minimum coverage, no backhaul etc) for 12 months.
Other operators have spectrum that could be used for higher bandwidth fixed wireless access services but deployments have been limited. For example, there has been some trial deployment by Ntl of 10 GHz equipment for its customers
Zipcom (formerly Radiotel) has a FWA licence suitable for narrowband services. Atlantic recently closed their FWA services following administration. The future of Ionica’s 3.4GHz and 10 GHz spectrum is also currently under consideration and a number of FWA licences are expected to be made available.
4.6 Mobile Higher Bandwidth Wireless Access
The Universal Mobile Telecommunication System ('UMTS') is a so-called "third-generation (3G)," broadband, packet-based system to be deployed in Europe for the transmission of text, digitised voice, video, and multimedia to mobile computer and phone users. The likely data rates range from about 144 kbps for fast moving users in rural areas, up to 384 kbps for slow moving users in urban/suburban areas, and perhaps up to 2Mbps for indoor users on pico cells (indoor base stations).
The UK auction for 5 UMTS licences was held in April 2000. The winners of this competition were the existing 4 GSM operators and TIW (which subsequently sold the licensee to Hutchison Whampoa). Due to lack of widespread availability of 3G handsets, commercial services may not be available until well into the year 2002, although Hutchison has stated plans for mid 2002.
4.7 Broadband Satellite Access
At the moment, some satellites in orbit around the Earth can offer broadband services, however data transfer has traditionally been in one direction only (from the network to the end user). Interactive applications have recently become available whereby a narrowband return path via the PSTN is used. The big two players in Europe are Eutelsat and SES (which operates the Astra fleet).
In July 2001, BTOpenworld announced that it would soon be offering two-way broadband satellite services to consumers in more remote parts of the UK (beginning in Northern Ireland and the Highlands and Islands of Scotland). BT will be in partnership with the satellite operator Gilat and expects to offer this service to home-based, small and medium sized businesses from November. This service will probably be based on VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) technology.
Eutelsat has submitted a proposal to the Department for Education and Employment’s (DFEE) ‘Wired Up Communities’ initiative. This proposal will offer satellite Internet access to homes in Cumbria, using the PSTN as return path.
5.1 Oftel’s aims
Oftel’s approach is to promote competition in the provision of access to the Internet and broadband services, thereby giving consumers a greater choice, better value and higher quality and spurring take up. Oftel seeks to match the level of regulation to the level of competition in the market, while continuing to protect and inform consumers where the market cannot do so.
5.2 Government initiatives
The Government’s aim is to make the UK the best place for e-commerce in the world by 2002 and to make the UK a leading knowledge economy and ecommerce nation. Major Government targets are:
The Office of the e-Envoy [OeE] is leading the Government’s drive to get the UK online and to ensure that the country, its citizens and its businesses derive maximum benefit from the knowledge economy. A UK Online Broadband Stakeholder Group has been set up, chaired by the e-Minister, to assist the Government in the development and implementation of broadband strategy. The group published an initial summary of its recommendations (25 September 2001) to drive forward the rollout of broadband services in the UK.
5.3 Definitions
This brief summarises the key developments in the market for Internet and broadband services in the UK, and describes Oftel’s involvement in these markets. ‘Dial-up’ or ‘narrowband’ Internet access is used in this brief for access speeds up to and including 128 kilobits per second (kbps). 'Broadband' is used in this brief to refer to higher bandwidth, always-on services, offering data rates of 128 kbps and above.